NSOs

How NSOs Are Taxed: Exercise, Withholding and Sale

With NSOs, the moment you exercise is the moment you owe tax, as ordinary income on the spread. Here's the math and how to plan it.

Published Sep 23, 20265 min readEducational, not tax advice
Figures for tax year

In plain English

A (NSO) is a right to buy company shares at a fixed . It's the most common kind of option for advisors, contractors and many employees.

NSOs are simpler than : the moment you buy the shares (), the profit on paper is taxed like salary. That profit is called the , the difference between what the shares are worth and what you paid.

After that, any further rise or fall in price is a or loss when you sell.

The simple rule

When you exercise a non-qualified stock option (NSO), the spread is :

Spread = (market value at exercise − strike price) × shares

For employees it's treated as wages: added to your , with federal (usually 22%), Social Security, Medicare and state tax. Growth after exercise is a capital gain when you sell.

An example

You exercise 5,000 NSOs with a $3 strike when the stock is $15.

  • Cash to exercise: $15,000
  • Ordinary income: $60,000 (with withholding)
  • Your : $15 per share
  • Sell 14 months later at $25: $50,000 long-term gain

Exercising at a private company

At a private company, the market value is the latest . You have to pay both the strike price and the withholding in cash, since you can't sell shares to cover it. That's why many people wait for an or .

Exercise-and-sell

After the IPO, the most common move is a : exercise and sell the same day. The whole spread is ordinary income, there's no extra capital gain, and the sale pays the strike and withholding.

NSOs vs ISOs

Both let you buy shares at a fixed price. The difference is when and how you're taxed:

  • NSOs are taxed at exercise. ISOs usually aren't, for regular tax.
  • NSOs never trigger .
  • NSOs get withholding. ISO disqualifying sales don't.
  • ISOs can become all long-term gain. NSO spread is always ordinary income.

Watch the withholding gap

Like , NSO income is withheld at 22%. High earners often owe more. See The RSU withholding gap; the same math applies.

Run it

Add an NSO grant in the calculator to see tax at exercise and after sale.

General information, not tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

How are NSOs taxed when I exercise my options?

When you exercise non-qualified stock options, the difference between the market value at exercise and your strike price is considered ordinary income. This amount is reported as wages on your W-2 and is subject to federal withholding, Social Security, Medicare, and state taxes.

What is the tax treatment if I exercise and sell NSOs on the same day?

If you perform a cashless exercise, the entire spread is taxed as ordinary income. Because you sell the shares immediately, there is no additional capital gain. The proceeds from the sale are used to cover your strike price and the required tax withholding.

How are NSOs different from ISOs regarding taxes?

NSOs are always taxed as ordinary income at the time of exercise, whereas ISOs are typically not taxed for regular income tax purposes upon exercise. Additionally, NSOs involve tax withholding and never trigger the alternative minimum tax, unlike ISOs which can eventually result in entirely long-term capital gains.

Do I have to pay taxes on NSOs at a private company if I cannot sell the shares?

Yes, you must pay both the strike price and the required tax withholding in cash at the time of exercise. Because you cannot sell private company shares to cover these costs, you are responsible for paying these amounts out of pocket using the latest 409A valuation to determine market value.

Official sources (for the detail-minded)

Run your own numbers

See your tax, take-home, and what to set aside. Free, and nothing is stored.

Open the calculator

Estimates only. Not tax, legal, or investment advice. See our methodology

Estimates only. Not tax, legal, or investment advice. See our methodology